The Pros and Cons of a Raw Food Diet for Dogs

2021-06-04
The Pros and Cons of a Raw Food Diet for Dogs

Raw food diets have become increasingly popular as alternatives to traditional dog food diets. Alongside many other dog food trends like grain-free, vegan or vegetarian, and the use of novel proteins, raw food diets have their pros and cons. Concern among veterinary professionals specifically lies in the safety of this type of diet while some pet owners and enthusiasts argue a raw diet is a healthier option for dogs.

What Is a Raw Food Diet for Dogs?

A raw food diet is one that does not contain cooked items. Unlike traditional, processed dog food, raw dog food does not come in a kibble or canned form. Freeze-dried and frozen options do exist for dog owners that appreciate convenience but still want to offer raw food. Fresh meat, often still on the bone, along with vegetables, grains, organ meats, eggs, fruit, and even some dairy may be part of a homemade, raw diet. Various recipes can be found online but some dog owners don't follow a recipe.

Why Do People Feed Raw Food Diets to Dogs?

Commercial dog food is nutritionally balanced, convenient, and affordable, yet despite these good qualities, some dog owners prefer raw food diets. A desire to feed more "natural" items, concerns with their dog's health, and trust issues with pet food manufacturers may lead a dog owner to go the raw route. Some owners even feel that since a dog's ancestors ate raw foods in the wild, their domesticated dog should, too.

Some dogs have food sensitivities or allergies that make it difficult to purchase commercially prepared diets. These dogs may benefit from a home-prepared meal and some owners opt to feed raw diets. A veterinary nutritionist should be involved in formulating a complete and balanced diet for a dog, even if a raw food diet is utilized, to ensure key nutrients will not be lacking.

What Nutritional Requirements Does a Dog Have?

Dogs can have different nutritional requirements if they have a specific disease but healthy puppies, adults, and pregnant or nursing dogs all require different things from their food, too. This is why different commercial diets exist for dogs in different life stages and also with different health problems. A six-month-old puppy does not have the same nutritional needs as a dog with kidney disease.

Nutrition affects internal organs, skin and coat, bones, muscles, and other parts of your dog, so it is more complicated than some pet owners may realize. Dogs need various vitamins, minerals, proteins, carbohydrates, fibers, and other ingredients to function normally and be healthy. If an improper diet is fed, dogs can develop serious, life-threatening issues, break bones, and not grow properly.

Dogs are omnivores so their nutritional needs reflect that. The Association of American Feed Control Officials (AAFCO) helps define and regulate what pets need and pet food manufacturers use these guidelines to make their foods. Domestic dogs are genetically different than their wolf ancestors so even though they are both canines, domestic dogs evolved to be able to digest starches.

Pros and Cons of Raw Food Diets for Dogs

Pros
  • More natural ingredients

  • Ability to choose exactly what your dog eats


    Ability to choose the source of your dog food ingredients

Cons
  • Potential for bacterial and parasitic contamination

  • Potential for nutritional imbalance

  • Potential for tooth injuries from bones

  • Expensive

  • Time consuming to prepare

The biggest concern people have with feeding raw food diets is the potential for bacterial and parasitic contamination and infection, even in previously frozen meats. Raw meats can harbor bacteria like Salmonella, Listeria, and E. coli as well as microscopic parasites like Sarcocystis and Toxoplasma. These pathogens can cause serious infections in both people and pets. Additionally, raw food diets are more expensive than commercially prepared kibble or canned food, can cause tooth injuries if they include bones, and are more time-consuming to prepare.

On the other hand, raw food dog diets allow a pet owner to choose exactly what their dog is eating. They can avoid specific ingredients, know what the sources of the ingredients, and can ensure their dog is getting a more natural diet like a wolf would eat.

Regardless of what type of diet you choose to feed your dog, make sure it is nutritionally complete and balanced. Dogs need more than just raw meat, so a veterinary nutritionist should be involved in formulating your dog's diet to ensure no nutrients are lacking.

Related Article

Is Neosporin Safe for Cats?

Is Neosporin Safe for Cats?

A brief summary of concerns a cat owner should be aware of before putting Neosporin on their cat, plus tips for things they can use at home instead.
18 Warning Signs That Your Cat Is Crying for Help

18 Warning Signs That Your Cat Is Crying for Help

How can you tell if your cat is sick? Learn about the warning signs indicating your cat is crying for help and find out what to do about them.
Chlamydia in Cats

Chlamydia in Cats

Chlamydia in cats is a bacterial infection primarily affecting the eyes, which can cause conjunctivitis. Learn the causes, treatment, and prevention.
Why Does My Kitten Bite Me? How to Stop Biting and Scratching in Kittens

Why Does My Kitten Bite Me? How to Stop Biting and Scratching in Kittens

Why does your kitten bite you? Play aggression is often the cause, but there may be other reasons for the scratching and biting. Here’s what to do if your cat bites and scratches you, including how to stop it.
200 Tortoiseshell Cat Names for Your Bi-Colored Kitty

200 Tortoiseshell Cat Names for Your Bi-Colored Kitty

Tortoiseshell cats are a rare phenomenon and deserve a fitting name. We've pulled together 200 tortoiseshell cat names, including male names, female names, cute names, and names inspired by their coat color and pattern.
12 Fluffy Cat Breeds Perfect for Endless Cuddles

12 Fluffy Cat Breeds Perfect for Endless Cuddles

If you like long-haired cats and don't mind daily (or almost daily) brushing, you’ll love these fluffy cat breeds.
10 Unique Bobtail Cat Breeds

10 Unique Bobtail Cat Breeds

Bobtail cat breeds, including the Manx and Cymric, result from natural genetic mutations. Learn whether one of these cats is right for you.
Burmese: Cat Breed Profile, Characteristics & Care

Burmese: Cat Breed Profile, Characteristics & Care

Known for their loving personality and muscular body, the Burmese loves to cuddle after a bout of kittenish playing. Learn about the Burmese breed.
Turkish Angora: Cat Breed Profile, Characteristics & Care

Turkish Angora: Cat Breed Profile, Characteristics & Care

The elegant and silky Turkish Angora cat is a playful, affectionate, and sometimes mischievous pet. Learn about the Turkish Angora breed.
Why Does My Cat Follow Me Around Everywhere?

Why Does My Cat Follow Me Around Everywhere?

Cats can follow their owners around for a few different reasons. Find out what your cat is trying to tell you if they follow you around.
Why Does My Cat Bite My Chin?

Why Does My Cat Bite My Chin?

If your cat is biting your chin, this might be a sign of affection, but it can also be caused by boredom or stress. Learn how to curb the behavior.
Common Causes of Mucus in Dog Poop

Common Causes of Mucus in Dog Poop

Seeing mucus in your dog's poop can be concerning to a dog owner. Here are common causes and treatment of mucus in a dog's stool.
Why Do Dogs Pant?

Why Do Dogs Pant?

Dogs pant for a number of reasons, including cooling, excitement, and play. But sometimes panting is a sign of a physical problem. Learn why dogs pant and what to do about it. Here’s how to tell if your dog’s panting is normal or a sign of a problem.
Intervertebral Disc Disease (IVDD) in Dogs

Intervertebral Disc Disease (IVDD) in Dogs

Intervertebral disc disease (IVDD), or a herniated disc, is a serious condition of the spinal cord. Learn the causes, treatment, and prevention.
Can Dogs Eat Watermelon?

Can Dogs Eat Watermelon?

Can dogs eat watermelon? Yes! But its important to keep certain precautions in mind. Learn the benefits, risks, and how to safely feed your dog this fruit.
Border Collie: Dog Breed Characteristics & Care

Border Collie: Dog Breed Characteristics & Care

Learn about the border collie, a popular herding breed. They're a smart and energetic dog that's also a great companion to the right pet parent.
Beagle: Dog Breed Characteristics & Care

Beagle: Dog Breed Characteristics & Care

Learn about the beagle, one of the most popular dog breeds in the world. They are known for being a cheerful, comical, loud, and energetic family dog.
Bluetick Coonhound: Dog Breed Characteristics & Care

Bluetick Coonhound: Dog Breed Characteristics & Care

Bluetick Coonhounds are a medium-size hound that are gentle and affectionate. They are commonly used as a raccoon hunting dog.
Tibetan Terrier: Dog Breed Characteristics & Care

Tibetan Terrier: Dog Breed Characteristics & Care

The Tibetan terrier is a happy-go-lucky dog with a shaggy coat. Learn more about the history, care tips, and other helpful information about the breed.
Lagotto Romagnolo: Dog Breed Characteristics & Care

Lagotto Romagnolo: Dog Breed Characteristics & Care

The Lagotto Romagnolo is an intelligent working breed from Northern Italy and can be an adaptable and laid back companion breed.